SeaWorld Ends Orca Breeding

In a not so surprising move SeaWorld have announced that they will no longer be breeding orca in captivity.

“By making this the last generation of orcas in our care and reimagining how guests will experience these beautiful animals, we are fulfilling our mission of providing visitors to our parks with experiences that matter,” said Joel Manby, president and CEO of SeaWorld Entertainment Inc.

The company currently has 23 orca in captivity, with at least one of those whales being pregnant. Naturally animal rights groups have welcomed the move after campaigning for years for Seaworld to give up using orca in their shows. In November, SeaWorld stopped their familiar “circus” style shows with orca in favour of offering “new, inspiring natural orca encounters” though we are still not clear on exactly what that entails as they won’t begin until 2017.

Whilst the move is welcomed there is little doubt that it stems from financial concerns rather than animal issues, SeaWorlds profits dropped 84% following the infamous “Blackfish” film and a move away from “circus orcas” is a bid to improve their image and bring visitors back. Director of Blackfish and staunch SeaWorld critic Gabriela Cowperthwaite released a joint statement with the Humane Society saying

“The fact that SeaWorld is doing away with orca breeding marks truly meaningful change”

11 of SeaWorlds 23 orca currently reside in their flagship park in San Diego. This park submitted $100 million development plan to the California Coastal Committee in October of 2015 which was approved but had several conditions, one of which was that SeaWorld could no longer breed orca. Effectively the ban on breeding was forced upon SeaWorld and today they have announced it as if it were their own idea, despite initially saying “a ban on breeding would sentence these animals to a slow extinction in our care” (2015).

So all in all a good move but one that they really had no choice over if they wished to survive as a company. With equal inevitability PETA director Mimi Bekhechi was still critical of SeaWorld saying:

“SeaWorld must open its tanks to the oceans to allow the orcas it now holds captive to have some semblance of a life outside these prison tanks,”

As SeaWorld correctly pointed out in response no whale or dolphin has ever been successfully released into the wild. Even Keiko, the wild born orca used in “Free Willy” failed to survive when reintroduced to the wild and so what PETA suggests is rather simplistic and unhelpful.

It is possible that this does mark the start of something new for Seaworld. They have formed a partnership with the animal rights group “The Humane Society” and have pledged $50 million to help whales and sharks in the wild whilst also promoting research in their San Diego redevelopment plan.

SeaWorld were always an easy target for criticism, much of it being deserved, but as Emily Stewart wrote they have always been quietly involved in a variety of conservation projects which do actually benefit the environment. The constant protesting and calls for SeaWorld to close entirely would impact conservation in ways most people just don’t realise. No conservation group is perfect, Greenpeace, Sea Shepherd and Friends of the Earth have all come under criticism for various illegal activities. SeaWorld certainly appear to be attempting to become better and an improved and ethical SeaWorld would be infinitely better than a closed SeaWorld.

2,109 total views, 2 views today

The following two tabs change content below.
Scott Thomson

Scott Thomson

Scott Thomson

Latest posts by Scott Thomson (see all)

You may also like...

2 Responses

  1. Thank you for reporting this Scott – it’s great news for animal welfare progress that Seaworld is ending it’s captive breeding program!

    I think the partnership is with The Humane Society in the U.S and not the Human Society. Can I also say that labelling all these organisation as “animal rights” groups sends the wrong message, perpetuating the perception of narrow-minded extremism and misrepresenting these groups. HSI says, “We are the leading animal advocacy organization, seeking a humane world for people and animals alike.” This point is often missed. We must surely aim to treat animals and humans with equal compassion and respect.

    I agree that PETA isn’t always mindful of what is possible and that releasing captive orca into the wild is unlikely to be a happy ending. Some have suggested a salt water ocean sanctuary. I have no idea of the practicality of this, or the costs, but Seaworld needs to give something back to the marine mammals they have long profited from.

    I agree also that not all zoos are created equal. While I don’t agree with large animals being held captive and I think welfare standards are seriously low in some zoos, other zoos can and do contribute to breeding programs and research and help fund conservation of species in other countries.

  1. 21st March 2016

    […] the social media tirade that has been Blackfish, Seaworld finally caved in and abolished its breeding programme of orcas as well as announced its new partnership with the Humane Society of the US (HSUS). A move that has […]

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Blue Captcha Image